电离层与对流层模型对北斗RAIM可用性的影响分析

doi:10.11959/j.issn.1000-436x.2015072

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

电离层和对流层是卫星导航系统测量的主要误差源，也是北斗卫星导航系统可用性变化的重要因素。采用星历数据仿真分析了电离层和对流层延迟误差模型对北斗导航系统RAIM可用性的影响，特别分析了不同对流层模型对民用航空的影响。实验表明电离层和对流层的延迟误差分别为0～14.555 9m及0～23.779 6m，且在民用航空的非精密进近阶段，用Saastamoinen 模型、UNB3模型及 Hopfield模型分别作为北斗的对流层误差模型的RAIM可用性分别为99.308%、92.041 5%和100%，相比较Hopfield模型更适合作为北斗卫星导航系统的对流层模型，能满足民用航空的99.9%RAIM可用性要求。

关键词: 北斗卫星导航系统, 电离层, 对流层, ；RAIM可用性, 非精密进近阶段

Abstract:

The ionosphere and troposphere are main error sources of satellite navigation system measurement and main factors of COMPASS availability. The influence of the ionosphere and troposphere delay error model on the RAIM availability of COMPASS is analyzed in simulation where ephemeris datum is adopted, and especially the influence of different troposphere models on RAIM availability in civil aviation is analyzed. The experiment at results shows that the delay error of ionosphere and troposphere changes from 0 to 14.555 9 m and 0 to 23.779 6 m correspondingly. And for the non-precision approach stage of civil aviation, when Saastamoinen model, UNB3 model and Hopfield model are used as the troposphere model of COMPASS respectively, the RAIM availability is 99.308%, 92.041 5% and 100% corre-spondingly. So it is more suitable that Hopfield model is used as the troposphere model of COMPASS and the 99.9% RAIM availability requirement in civil aviation can be achieved using this model.

Key words: COMPASS, ionosphere, troposphere, RAIM availability, non-precision approach

焦卫东,唐志虎,沈笑云. 电离层与对流层模型对北斗RAIM可用性的影响分析[J]. 通信学报, 2015, 36(3): 179-186.

Wei-dong JIAO,Zhi-hu TANG,Xiao-yun SHEN. Analysis of influence of ionosphere and troposphere model on RAIM availability of COMPASS[J]. Journal on Communications, 2015, 36(3): 179-186.

图/表 5

图1

表1

图2

图3

图4

参考文献 23

[1]	任锴，杨力，冯勇．两种RAIM可用性分析方法的比较[J]．遥测遥控， 2009,30(2):1-3. REN K , YANG L , FENG Y . Comparison of two RAIM availability analysis approaches[J]. Journal of Telemetry, Tracking and Command, 2009,30(2):1-3.
[2]	蔡清毅．基于性能导航（PBN）技术介绍[J]．空中交通管理， 2011,15(4):1-2. CAI Q Y . Introduction to performance based navigation (PBN) tech-nologies[J]. Air Traffic Management, 2011,15(4):1-2.
[3]	孙隽，韦萍萍． GPS+BD 双模接收机自主完好性监测算法研究[J]．计算机技术与发展， 2013,23(7):1-2. SUN J , WEI P P . Research on RAIM algorithm of GPS+BD double model receiver[J]. Computer Technology and Development, 2013,23(7):1-2.
[4]	王彩霞． GPS RAIM 预测系统的设计和算法研究[J]．现代导航， 2012,3:165-171. WANG C X . Design and algorithm study of GPS RAIM prediction system[J]. Modern Navigation, 2012,3:165-171.
[5]	FILIPE S , JOSé S , ANTóNIO R . Weighted total least squares RAIM algorithm using carrier phase measurements[J]. Satellite Navigation Technologies and European Workshop on GNSS Signals and Signal Processing, 2012,6:1-6.
[6]	朱衍波，张淼艳，张军．加权RAIM可用性预测方法研究[J]．遥测遥控， 2009,30(1):3-6. ZHU Y B , ZHANG M Y , ZHANG J . Research on weighted algorithm to predict RAIM availability[J]. Journal of Telemetry, Tracking and Command, 2009,30(1):3-6.
[7]	徐肖豪，杨传森，刘瑞华． GNSS 用户端自主完好性监测研究综述[J]．航空学报， 2013,34(3):3-9. XU X H , YANG C S , LIU R H . Review and prospect of GNSS re-ceiver autonomous integrity monitoring[J]. Acta Aeronautica Et As-tronautica Sinica, 2013,34(3):3-9.
[8]	卢虎，廉杰．北斗用户机自主完好性监测研究[J]．空中工程大学学报， 2010,11(3):1-5. LU H , LIAN J . Research on RAIM algorithm of Beidou receiver[J]. Proceedings of the Air of Engineering University, 2010,11(3):1-5.
[9]	郁聪冲，边少峰．现阶段北斗卫星导航系统可用性分析[J]．海洋测绘， 2012,32(5):1-3. YU C C , BIAN S F . Usability analysis of Beidou satellite navigation system at the present stage[J]. Hydrographic Surveying and Charting, 2012,32(5):1-3.
[10]	WU X L , HU X G , WANG G , ZHONG H J , TANG C P . Evaluation of COMPASS ionospheric model in GNSS positioning[J]. Advances in Space Research, 2012,51(6):959-968.
[11]	LEANDRO R F , SANTOS M C , LANGLEY R B . UNB neutral at-mosphere models: development and performance[J]. Proceedings of ION NTM, 2006,1:564-573.
[12]	DODSON A H , CHEN W , BAKER H C , PENNA N T . Assessment of EGNOS tropospheric correction model[A]. Proceedings of the 12th International Technical Meeting of the Satellite Division of The Institute of Navigation[C]. 1999.1401-1408.
[13]	宋淑丽，朱文耀，陈钦明等．中国区域对流层延迟改正模型（SHAO）的初步建立[A]．中国卫星导航学术年会组委会[C]. 2010.557-566. SONG S L , ZHU Y W , CHEN Q M , et al. China regional tropospheric delay correction model (SHAO) preliminary established[A]. The Or-ganizing Committee of the Chinese Satellite Navigation Academic Conference[C]. 2010.557-566.
[14]	李薇，袁运斌，欧吉坤等．全球对流层天顶延迟模型IGGtrop的建立于分析[J]．科学通报， 2012,57(15):1317-1325. XU X H , YANG C S , LIU R H , et al. Review and prospect of GNSS re-ceiver autonomous integrity monitoring[J]. Acta Aeronautica Et As-tronautica Sinica, 2012,57(15):1317-1325.
[15]	郭睿，郑勇，杜兰． GPS和Galileo系统下RAIM算法可用性分析[J]．测绘科学技术学报， 2006,23(6):1-2. GUO R , ZHENG Y , DU L . Analysis on RAIM availability of different navigation systems[J]. Journal of Geometrics Science and Technology, 2006,23(6):1-2.
[16]	张军．空地协同的空域监视新技术[M]．北京：航空工业出版社， 2011,30-31. ZHANG J . Air-ground Collaborative Airspace Surveillance[M]. Beijing: AviationIndustryPress, 2011,30-31.
[17]	MCGRAW G A . Tropospheric error modeling for high integrity air-borne GNSS navigation[J]. Position Location and Navigation Symposium, 2012,4:158-166.
[18]	L?FGREN J S , BJ?RNDAHL F , MOORE A W . Tropospheric correction for InSAR using interpolated ECMWF data and GPS zenith total delay from the southern California integrated GPS network[J]. Geo-science and Remote Sensing Symposium, 2010,7:4503-4506.
[19]	RTCA DO-208. Minimum Operational Performance Standards for Airborne Supplemental Navigation Equipment Using Global Positioning System[S]. USA: RTCA, 1991.
[20]	JOKINEN A , FENG S J , OCHIENG W . Fixed ambiguity precise point positioning(PPP) with FDE RAIM[J]. Position Location and Navigation Symposium, 2012,4:643-658.
[21]	PRATAP MISRA , PER E . Global Positioning System: Signal, Meas-urements, and Performance[M]. Beijing: Electronics Industry Press 2008:176-178.
[22]	中国卫星导航系统管理办公室．北斗卫星导航系统空间信号接口控制文件公开服务信号B1I(1.0版)[EB/OL]. www.beidou.gov.cn/attach, 2012-12-27/2013-11-24.China's Satellite Navigation System Management Office. Beidou Satellite Navigation System Space Signals Interface Control File Public Service B1I(1.0)[EB/OL]. www.beidou.gov.cn/attach 2012-12-27/2013-11-24.
[23]	周命端，郭际明，祥广． GPS对流层延迟改正UNB3模型及其精度分析[J]．测绘信息与工程， 2008,33(4):1-3. ZHOU M D , GUO J M , MENG X G. . GPS tropospheric delay model UNB3 and ITS accuracy analysis[J]. Journal of Geomatrics, 2008,33(4):1-3.

性能需求	远洋航路	本土航路	终端区	非精密进近
精度（95%）	2.0 nmile	1.0 nmile	0.4 nmile	220 m
告警限值	4.0 nmile	2.0 nmile	1.0 nmile	0.3 nmile
告警时间	1 min	30 s	10 s	10 s
漏警率	0.001	0.001	0.001	0.001
误警率	0.000 01/h	0.000 01/h	0.000 01/h	0.000 01/h
可用性	99.9%	99.9%	99.9%	99.9%